| Season | Most Valuable Player | Matthew Luckey Memorial Outstanding Defenseman | Outstanding Goaltender | Leading Scorer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spring 2023 | Dan Hopper, Purple Haze | Greg Adams, East Side Knights | Chris Kunik, East Side Knights | Nick Velissaris, The Avengers | |
| Fall 2022 | Jordan Ades, Team Big Happy | Ken Zach, Team Big Happy | Jake Ades, Team Big Happy |
|
|
| Spring 2022 | Dan Hopper, Purple Haze | Rob Lozinski, Dept of Media | Jon LaRosa, Purple Haze | Rob Lozinski, Dept of Media | |
| Fall 2021 | Matt Hankin, East Side Knights | Rob Lozinski, Dept of Hitmen | Eitan Levine, Dept of Hitmen | Dan Hopper, Purple Haze | |
| Spring 2021 | Jon Winawer, Sons of Anarchy | Evan Jacobs, Sons of Anarchy | Jon Winawer, Sons of Anarchy | Travis Terzer, Sons of Anarchy | |
| Fall 2019 | Jason LeBorgne, Hudson Hitmen | Tim Menz, Otters | Adam Kessler, The Ainsworth | Sean McGrath, The Ainsworth | |
| Spring 2019 | Alex Morin, Dept of Media | Matt Luckey, FP Associates / Mike Rossi, The Meese | Jon LaRosa, FP Associates | Ian Bass, The Dogs / Alex Morin, Dept. of Media | |
| Fall 2018 | Tim Lockwood, FP Associates | Josh Haberman, Angry Dragons/ Matt Luckey, FP Associates | Jon LaRosa, FP Associates |
Tim Lockwood, FP Associates |
|
| Spring 2018 | Drake DeBono, The Warriors / Matt Rappe, The Meese | Nicholas Parilla, Team Apocalypse | Steve Pinell, The Warriors | Matt Rappe, The Meese | |
| Fall 2017 |
Hector Martinez, Team USA / Sean McGrath, The Ainsworth |
Derek Sandberg, The Ainsworth | Charles Kalter, Team USA | Hector Martinez, Team USA | |
| Spring 2017 | Sean McGrath, The Ainsworth | Matt Luckey, FP Associates | Adam Feld, Dept. of Media | Sean McGrath, The Ainsworth | |
| Fall 2016 | Wes Bronson,The Ainsworth | Mike Kapnick, Ducks | Adam Butensky, The Ainsworth | Hector Martinez, Team USA | |
| Spring 2016 | Josh Moelis, EY | Brian Davis, EY | Zach Abrams, EY | Josh Moelis, EY | |
| Fall 2015 | Jeff Hu, Bounce SC | Randy Zia, Mustangs | Charles Kalter, Bounce SC | Jonathan Cohen, Markit Maniacs | |
| Spring 2015 | Josh Moelis, EY | Tyler Morrell, Team USA | Jesse Silverberg, Gate 8 Otters | Josh Moelis, EY | |
| Fall 2014 | David Okane, A-Team | Tim Menz, Gate 8 Otters | David Okane, A-Team | Joseph Koressel, Gate 8 Otters | |
| Spring 2014 | Kevin Hill, A-Team | Matt Bruno, Skyliners | David Rifkin, Markit Maniacs | Kevin Hill, A-Team | |
| Fall 2013 | Mike Fitoussi, Team USA | Josh Brower, Greylock | Sean McKinney, Greylock | Dave Berg, American Whiskey |
