| Season | Most Valuable Player | Outstanding Defenseman | Outstanding Goaltender | Leading Scorer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spring 2023 | Grahm McGlinchey, Hooligans | Ben Miller, Rollerbucks | Mike Sliwka, Hooligans | Nick Quillan, HockeyXP |
| Fall 2022 | Rich Grant, Hooligans | Aidan Cleary, Ainsworth | Eitan Levine, Dept of Media | Rich Grant, Hooligans |
| Spring 2022 | Sean McGrath, Ainsworth | Aidan Cleary, Ainsworth | Steve Friedman, Slicelanders | Sean McGrath, Ainsworth |
| Fall 2021 | Richie Mauri, The Warriors | Jesse Deatherage, Team USA | Steve Pinell, The Warriors | Sean McGrath, Ainsworth |
| Spring 2021 | Mike Rossi, The Meese | Joe Jensen, Chiefs | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | Joe Jensen, Chiefs |
| Fall 2019 | Mike Landa, Rathbones Roller Bucks | Ross Ginsberg, Chiefs | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | Mike Landa, Rathbones Roller Bucks |
| Spring 2019 | Steve Carro, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jon Erikson, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jason Romano, Wangs Fried Chicken | Steve Carro, Wangs Fried Chicken |
| Fall 2018 | Dan Bogart, Chiefs | Ross Ginsberg, Chiefs/ Mike Kapnick, Ducks | Kevin Norwin, Rathbone's Roller Bucks | Dan Bogart, Chiefs |
| Spring 2018 | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Justin Buchel, Mighty Mouses | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses |
| Fall 2017 | Bryan Bergstol, Skyliners | Tim Menz, Gate 8 Otters | Jason Romano, Wangs Fried Chicken | Zack Soss, Camels |
| Spring 2017 | Jon Erikson, Wangs Fried Chicken | Ryan Quinn, Ducks | Ethan Lippman, PwC | Jon Erikson, Wangs Fried Chicken |
| Fall 2016 | Jake Levy, EY | Brian Pershinsky, Mustangs | Joe Fried, Skyliners/ Jason Romano, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jake Levy, EY |
| Spring 2016 | Charles Delkeskamp, Skyliners | Matt Bruno, Skyliners | John Battaglia, Mustangs / Charles Kalter, Bounce SC | Dylan Farrugia, Mustangs |
| Fall 2015 | Charles Delkeskamp, Skyliners | Matt Bruno, Skyliners | Jesse Silverberg, Gate 8 Otters / Joey Rosenberg, Spectra Audio | Charles Delkeskamp, Skyliners |
| Spring 2015 | Charles Delkeskamp, Skyliners | Matt Bruno, Skyliners | Ethan Lippman, American Whiskey | Charles Delkeskamp, Skyliners |
| Fall 2014 |
Perry Clarkson, Greylock |
Josh Brower, Greylock | EJ Assi, Chiefs | Perry Clarkson, Greylock |
| Spring 2014 | Matt Ramoundos, District 5 | Randy Zia, Mustangs | Sean McKinney, Greylock | Matt Ramoundos, District 5 |
| Fall 2013 | EJ Assi, Chiefs | Jason Machowsky, Chiefs | EJ Assi, Chiefs | Dan Someck, Chiefs |
| Spring 2013 | Garrett Grant, Mustangs | Russell Feathers, Spectra Audio | John Battaglia, Mustangs | Seamus McKillop, Spectra Audio |
| Fall 2012 | Ian Freidland, District 5 | Brian McCabe, PwC | Dan Leiro, PwC | Ian Freidland, District 5 |
