At the conclusion of each season during individual awards voting, ten players are recognized for their outstanding play and named to the post-season all-star teams. The second team consists of a goaltender, two forwards, and two defensemen, who were judged to have outstanding seasons.
T1 2nd Team All Stars
Tier 1 Post-Season Second Team All-Stars
| Season | Goaltender | Defenseman | Defenseman | Forward | Forward |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spring 2022 | Taylor Levy, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jeremiah Ledwidge, Greylock | Jake Levy, High Rollers | Jon Erickson, Wangs Fried Chicken | Brett Jackson, TnT |
| Fall 2021 | Jon Winawer, smt High Rollers | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Andrew Green, Spectra Audio | Jon Ison, Bearcats | Jon Erickson, Spectra Audio |
| Spring 2021 | Matt Tatarian, Spectra Audio | Russell Feathers, Spectra Audio | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Brandon Harrington, smt High Rollers | Jake Levy, smt High Rollers |
| Fall 2019 | Jesse Silverberg, High Rollers | Ricky McGuire, smt Expo | Johnny Tkaczuk, High Rollers | Alex Morin, Spectra Audio | Brett Jackson, High Rollers |
| Spring 2019 | Ethan Lippman, Spectra Audio | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Jason Derector, Spectra Audio | Zach Rogow, Sharks | Charlie Delkeskamp, High Rollers |
| Fall 2018 | Jesse Silverberg, High Rollers | Ricky McGuire, smt Expo | Jeremiah Ledwidge, Special Delivery | Zach Rogow, Sharks | Joe Livesy, Bearcats |
| Spring 2018 | Ron Lopez, smt Expo | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Rob Pfiefer, Bearcats | George Liapis, High Rollers | Evan Chlanda, Lions |
| Fall 2017 | Jesse Silverberg, Special Delivery | Ricky McGuire, smt Expo | Jeremiah Ledwidge, Special Delivery | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Mike Gardner, smt Expo |
| Spring 2017 | Matt Tatarian, Sharks | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery | Jeremiah Ledwidge, Special Delivery | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Evan Chlanda, Lions |
| Fall 2016 | Tiffer Valente, Special Delivery | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Kevin Lipson, Sharks | John Baum, Greylock | Alec Kirschner, Mighty Mouses |
| Spring 2016 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Adam Root, smt Expo | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Evan Chlanda, Lions |
| Fall 2015 | Justin Buchel, Mighty Mouses | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Kevin Lipson, Sharks | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Eli Bernstein, Greylock |
| Spring 2015 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Bob Markowick, Sharks | Adam Root, smt Expo | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Mike Coyle, Bearcats |
| Fall 2014 | Adam Blitzer, smt Expo | Sean McGrath, Whiskey Rebel | Adam Root, smt Expo | Connor Cafferty, Lions | Joe Jensen, Brick Run |
| Spring 2014 | Adam Blitzer, smt Expo | Dan Glaser, smt Expo | Rob Pfiefer, Bearcats | Josh Gold, smt Expo | Steve Carro, East End Terriers |
| Fall 2013 | Ron Lopez, East End Terriers | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Chris Moreira, Lions | Justin Kozik, smt Expo |
| Spring 2013 | Anthony Vertullo, Wharf Bar | Rob Gallion, Lions | Danny Genovese, East End Terriers | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Justin Kozik, smt Expo |
| Fall 2012 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Rob Gallion, Lions | Damian Briggs, Dylan Murphy's | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Steven Gaon, Special Delivery |
| Spring 2012 | Adam Blitzer, smt Expo | Dan Glaser, smt Expo | Pat Yorke, Wharf Bar | Chris Moreira, Lions | Mike Marian, East End Terriers |
| Fall 2011 | Anthony Vertullo, Wharf Bar | Rob Gallion, Lions | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Mike Pelliccione, smt Expo | Mike Martucci, Dylan Murphy's |
| Spring 2011 | Ron Lopez, East End Terriers | Rob Gallion, Lions | Scott Pollak, East End Terriers | Chris Moreira, Lions | Seth Rubin, Lions |
| Fall 2010 | Justin Buchel, Mighty Mouses | Dan Glaser, Mighty Mouses | Jon Erickson, Wangs Fried Chicken | Eric Levee, smt Expo | Eddie Chlanda, Chiefs |
| Spring 2010 | Eric Gallion, Chiefs | Dan Glaser, Mighty Mouses | Phil Hoffman, East End Terriers | Jason Schwab, The Ainsworth | Mike Marian, East End Terriers |
| Fall 2009 | Eric Gallion, Chiefs | Mike Fioretti, PWC | Mike Bagliebter, The Ainsworth | Brian Fioretti, PWC | Rob Oram, Sharks |
| Spring 2009 | John Battaglia, Alumni | Scott Pollack, East End Terriers | Martin Angert, Special Delivery | Mike Freidman, PWC | Brandon Farrugia, Mustangs |
| Fall 2008 | Ron Lopez, East End Terriers | Dan Belair, Sharks | Mike Bagliebter, The Ainsworth | Ben Zises, Alumni | Scott Kotchek, Special Delivery |
| Spring 2008 | John Battaglia, Alumni | Adam Root, smt Expo | Adam Karafoil, Alumni | Mike Pelliccione, smt Expo | Scott Kotchek, Special Delivery |
| Fall 2007 | Robbie Gerson, Special Delivery | Josh Marcus, The Ainsworth | Corey Cohen, Traffix | Ross Ginsberg, Chiefs | Dan Someck, Chiefs |
| Summer 2007 | Scott Richman, smt Expo | Brian Yeilding, Sharks | Corey Cohen, Traffix | Sam Zises, Alumni | Jonathan Lawrence, Lions |
