| Season | Most Valuable Player | Outstanding Defenseman | Outstanding Goaltender | Leading Scorer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spring 2022 | Steve Tomczyk, Raging Mingos | Rich Mauri, Warriors | Steve Tomczyk, Raging Mingos | Brett Jackson, Trinidad & Tobago |
| Fall 2022 | Dustin Rabinowitz, The Meese | Randy Zia, Team USA | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | Dustin Rabinowitz, The Meese / Rocco Miano, Trinidad & Tobago |
| Spring 2022 | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses |
| Fall 2021 | Brett Jackson, Trinidad and Tobago | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Steve Tomczyk, Chiefs | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses / Brett Jackson, Trinidad and Tobago |
| Spring 2021 | Jon Ison, Bearcats | Zach Kiel, Mighty Mouses | Jason Romano, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jon Ison, Bearcats |
| Fall 2019 | Zach Rogow, Sharks | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery | Matt Tatarian, Sharks | Zach Rogow, Sharks |
| Spring 2019 | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Perry Clarkson, Greylock/ Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Sean McKinney, Greylock | Perry Clarkson, Greylock |
| Fall 2018 | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Ethan Lippman, PWC | Perry Clarkson, Greylock |
| Spring 2018 | David Friedman, Sharks | Kevin Lipson, Sharks | AJ Frey / Matt Tatarian, Sharks | David Friedman, Sharks |
| Fall 2017 |
Tom Conway, American Whiskey / Johnny Tkaczuk, Move Well MD |
Russell Feathers, Spectra Audio / Johnny Tkaczuk, Move Well MD | Jesse Silverberg, Move Well MD | Thomas Conway, American Whiskey / Johnny Tkaczuk, Move Well MD |
| Spring 2017 | Jon Ison, Syska Bearcats | Rob Pfeifer, Syska Bearcats | Ethan Lippman, American Whiskey | Andrew Macchio, American Whiskey |
| Fall 2016 | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Russell Feathers, Spectra Audio | Charles Kalter, Bounce SC | David Aaron, Mighty Mouses |
| Spring 2016 | Joe Livsey, Syska Bearcats | Boris Dikovsky, Syska Bearcats |
Jesse Silverberg, Gate 8 Otters |
Joe Livsey, Syska Bearcats |
| Fall 2015 | Dan Bogart, Chiefs | Jeremiah Ledwidge, Special Delivery | Ethan Lippman, American Whiskey | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery |
| Spring 2015 | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery | Pete O'Connell, D5 | Ron Lopez, Chiefs | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery |
| Fall 2014 |
Alec Kirschner, Mighty Mouses/ Ian Freidland, D5 |
Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Justin Buchel, Mighty Mouses | Alec Kirschner, Mighty Mouses |
| Spring 2014 | Dan McGrath, Brick Run | Shaun McGrath, Brick Run | Al Hadzovic, Brick Run | Dan McGrath, Brick Run |
| Fall 2013 | Shaun McGrath, Brick Run | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Al Hadzovic, Brick Run | Dan McGrath, Brick Run |
| Spring 2013 | Mike Coyle, Syska Bearcats | Dan Porcelli, Dylan Murphy's | Al Hadzovic, Dylan Murphy's | Joe Livsey, Syska Bearcats |
| Fall 2012 | Anthony Tisgourakos, Sharkz | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | Robin Alama, Brick-Run | Joe Jensen, Brick Run |
| Spring 2012 | Jared Feigenbaum, Mighty Mouses | Jason Aaron, Mighty Mouses | John Battaglia, Mustangs | Jared Feigenbaum, Mighty Mouses |
| Fall 2011 | Dennis McGloughlin, Mustangs | Anthony Janetta, Wangs Fried Chicken | Bobby Benson, The Ainsworth | Chase Sandler, Special Delivery |
| Spring 2011 | Dan McGrath, Brick Run | Lou Ambriano, Dylan Murphy's | Jeremy Schloss, Dylan Murphy's | Dan McGrath, Brick Run |
