At the conclusion of each season during individual awards voting, ten players are recognized for their outstanding play and named to the post-season all-star teams. The first team consists of a goaltender, two forwards, and two defensemen, judged to be the best players at their positions. The second team repeats that format.
Tier 1 Post Season All- Star Teams
Tier 1 Post-Season First Team All-Stars
| Season | Goaltender | Defenseman | Defenseman | Forward | Forward |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spring 2022 | Steve Tomczyk, Spectra Audio | Robbie Fulton, Spectra Audio | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Zach Rogow, High Rollers | Jon Ison, Bearcats |
| Fall 2021 | Steve Tomczyk, Spectra Audio | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Robbie Fulton, Spectra Audio | Zach Rogow, smt High Rollers | Alex Morin, Spectra Audio |
| Spring 2021 | Ron Lopez, smt High Rollers | Zach Rogow, Spectra Audio | Johnny Tkaczuk, smt High Rollers | Brett Novick, Greylock | Alex Morin, Spectra Audio |
| Fall 2019 | Adam Feld, Lions | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Evan Chlanda, Lions |
| Spring 2019 | Jesse Silverberg, High Rollers | Ricky McGuire, smt Expo | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Liam McKillop, Spectra Audio | Brandon Harrington, smt Expo |
| Fall 2018 | Brendan Mcfarland, Bearcats | Boris Dikovsky, Bearcats | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Jon Ison, Bearcats | Dave Friedman, Sharks |
| Spring 2018 | Jesse Silverberg, High Rollers | Rob Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Joe Livesy, Bearcats |
| Fall 2017 | Ron Lopez, smt Expo | Rob Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery | Brandon Harrington, smt Expo |
| Spring 2017 | Sean McKinney, Greylock | Rob Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Shawn Hroch, Lions | Andrew Brodsky, Sharks |
| Fall 2016 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Rob Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Andrew Brodsky, Sharks |
| Spring 2016 | Tiffer Valente, Special Delivery | Rob Gallion, Lions | Kevin Lipson, Sharks | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery | Andrew Brodsky, Sharks |
| Fall 2015 | Sean McKinney, Greylock | Rob Gallion, Lions | Perry Clarkson, Greylock | Alec Kirschner, Mighty Mouses | Andrew Brodsky, Sharks |
| Spring 2015 | Adam Blitzer, smt Expo | Rob Gallion, Lions | Rob Pfiefer, Bearcats | Alec Kirschner, Mighty Mouses | Andrew Brodsky, Sharks |
| Fall 2014 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Rob Gallion, Lions | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Dan McGrath, Brick Run |
| Spring 2014 | AJ Frey, Sharks | Rob Gallion, Lions | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Bob Markowick, Sharks |
| Fall 2013 | Amit Sinha, Bearcats | Rob Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Connor Cafferty, Lions |
| Spring 2013 | Eric Gallion, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Chris Moreira, Lions | Marc Pantirer, smt Expo |
| Fall 2012 | Anthony Pedalino, East End Terriers | Adam Root, smt Expo | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Josh Gold, smt Expo | Cory Greenberg, Special Delivery |
| Spring 2012 | Anthony Vertullo, Wharf Bar | Adam Root, smt Expo | Jeff Olsen, East End Terriers | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Marc Pantirer, smt Expo |
| Fall 2011 | Anthony Dascal, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Ryan Farrell, Chiefs | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Jon Foster, Wharf Bar |
| Spring 2011 | Eric Gallion, Chiefs | Adam Root, smt Expo | Ryan Farrell, Chiefs | Mike Gardner, smt Expo | Mike Pelliccione, smt Expo |
| Fall 2010 | Mike Hauptman, Special Delivery | Adam Root, smt Expo | Dave Rosenberg, Wangs Fried Chicken | Jeremy Kaufman, E&Y | Josh Gold,smt Expo |
| Spring 2010 | Adam Blitzer/Roxanne Gaudiel, Lions | Adam Root, smt Expo | Dave Rosenberg, Wangs Fried Chicken | Mike Friedman, PWC | Brandon Gregor, Lions |
| Fall 2009 | Ron Lopez, East End Terriers | Adam Root, smt Expo | Dan Glaser, Mighty Mouses | Mike Friedman, PWC | Josh Moelis, E&Y |
| Spring 2009 | Ron Lopez, East End Terriers | Adam Root, smt Expo | Dan Glaser, Mighty Mouses | Brian Fioretti, PWC | Josh Moelis, E&Y |
| Fall 2008 | Joe Held, PWC | Adam Root, smt Expo | Mike Fioretti, PWC | Brandon Gregor, Sharks | Rob Oram, Sharks |
| Spring 2008 | Tommy Matais, Traffix | Reilly Olson, Lions | Mike Fioretti, PWC | Mike Friedman, Alumni | Rob Oram, Sharks |
| Fall 2007 | Joshua McKee, Lions | Reilly Olson, Lions | Chris Pelka, Lions | Mike Friedman, Alumni | Ben Zises, Alumni |
| Spring 2007 | Adam Blitzer, E&Y | Adam Root, smt Expo | Reilly Olson, Lions | Mike Friedman, Alumni | Ben Zises, Alumni |
